Official Luthiers Forum! http://luthiersforum.com/forum/ |
|
Takamine Neck Reset Journey http://luthiersforum.com/forum/viewtopic.php?f=10137&t=51603 |
Page 2 of 3 |
Author: | Barry Daniels [ Tue Jun 04, 2019 10:07 am ] |
Post subject: | Re: Takamine Neck Reset Journey |
The heel should have no glue AT ALL! |
Author: | Chowlie [ Tue Jun 04, 2019 11:28 am ] |
Post subject: | Re: Takamine Neck Reset Journey |
Thanks guys, I will certainly follow your experience next time around. That being said, what methods do you use to floss the joint? |
Author: | Bryan Bear [ Tue Jun 04, 2019 12:17 pm ] |
Post subject: | Re: Takamine Neck Reset Journey |
With the neck held in position, insert sandpaper strips between the body and the neck and pull it through while holding the neck to the body. As the back of the paper rides the body the cutting side sands the body shape into the neck heel. By altering the number of strokes and how much you sand each surface, you can make adjustments to the neck angle and center aliment. |
Author: | Chowlie [ Tue Jun 04, 2019 12:20 pm ] |
Post subject: | Re: Takamine Neck Reset Journey |
Good deal. That's how I altered the angle on this guitar. I suppose it's something that will take patience and practice. |
Author: | Chowlie [ Tue Jun 04, 2019 1:01 pm ] |
Post subject: | Re: Takamine Neck Reset Journey |
Next on the block, probably. Attachment: Screenshot_20190604-135607_QuickPic.jpg Attachment: 20190601_123931-min.jpg Look closely... yes, another Takamine. Seems like this neck design could be attached with dowel rods instead of a dovetail. May be able to actually heat this one off. |
Author: | Chowlie [ Fri Aug 16, 2019 11:42 am ] |
Post subject: | Re: Takamine Neck Reset Journey |
Followup on the last post I made. This guitar presents a new set of challenges with a cutaway and wide/flat neck heel. The f/b extension was very difficult to loosen on this guitar. Something about 45 years of hardened epoxy, probably. Nonetheless, it finally gave up but took some spruce with it. Attachment: 20190729_211118.jpg Attachment: 20190730_211414.jpg Using the wire EDM at work, I removed all the dead space from the end of my Japanese saw so I could effectively cut square into the neck heel and not remove the fretboard. It worked pretty well, but due to the different angles I was working with - and no side wood to help maintain flatness near the cutaway - I cut into the side wood of the guitar's body a bit. Here you can see that I've already drilled bolt holes in the body. I should have done it this way with the last guitar, but I suppose lesson learned. Attachment: 20190808_205106.jpg I've already relived the heel in the this photo and marked where the thread inserts need to go. Sadly the existing dowels caused the drill bit to wander, so I need to re-drill those larger and glue in even bigger dowels. Attachment: 20190808_205818.jpg So right now I'm looking at replacing the piece of trim on the body that I cut into, and gluing in a thin piece of "something" to sand back down where I removed the side wood. Any suggestions for this process? |
Author: | flemsmith [ Fri Aug 16, 2019 5:54 pm ] |
Post subject: | Re: Takamine Neck Reset Journey |
Not sure what you actually did to your razor saw with the wire EDM. Can show a pix? My razor saw only has about the last two inches sans the supporting metal backing. I managed to saw thru to the fretboard just using the end of the saw, but it was a bit tricky. I may have to buy one of the stew Mac saws. Wonder if you could clamp a guide on the cutaway side? Nice job of sharing. Thanks. Roy |
Author: | Chowlie [ Mon Aug 19, 2019 8:01 am ] |
Post subject: | Re: Takamine Neck Reset Journey |
flemsmith wrote: Not sure what you actually did to your razor saw with the wire EDM. Can show a pix? My razor saw only has about the last two inches sans the supporting metal backing. I managed to saw thru to the fretboard just using the end of the saw, but it was a bit tricky. I may have to buy one of the stew Mac saws. Wonder if you could clamp a guide on the cutaway side? Nice job of sharing. Thanks. Roy Here you go - this is a StewMac saw too. I just removed the very tip without any teeth on it. Attachment: 68821132_348818832736823_5407363254433349632_n.jpg
|
Author: | Chowlie [ Mon Aug 19, 2019 8:16 am ] |
Post subject: | Re: Takamine Neck Reset Journey |
Got the inserts in place, but neither hole is perfectly aligned to the body. I think I'll just have to drill the body holes out larger and maybe use a stainless plate like I did on the Parlor guitar. Attachment: 20190817_121836.jpg Binding removed. Attachment: 20190817_121757.jpg
|
Author: | Chowlie [ Mon Aug 19, 2019 9:09 am ] |
Post subject: | Re: Takamine Neck Reset Journey |
So as not to hide my non-professional skills, I just wanted to point out this booger. I made the mistake of lightly tapping the dowel into place, and it popped out the mahogany on the neck heel. You can also see a line on the edge of the heel that has been re-glued - this was due to using a chisel on it at a poor angle and causing it to split. Several curse words were used during this process. Shame on me, but I did learn another two lessons this time around. Sadly I have more guitars with this same type of thin doweled-on heel, and they're very difficult to work with. I always tell myself "nothing can be broken that can't be fixed somehow." I'll cover it back up with polyurethane and make it as nice as possible. Attachment: 20190817_121151.jpg
|
Author: | flemsmith [ Mon Aug 19, 2019 11:10 am ] |
Post subject: | Re: Takamine Neck Reset Journey |
Looks like you filed or sanded off the head of the brass inserts..is that because you weren't sure you had enough heel wood to sink them below the surface? Was it difficult to do that without overly impacting the heel connecting wood surface? Roy |
Author: | Chowlie [ Mon Aug 19, 2019 11:28 am ] |
Post subject: | Re: Takamine Neck Reset Journey |
flemsmith wrote: Looks like you filed or sanded off the head of the brass inserts..is that because you weren't sure you had enough heel wood to sink them below the surface? Was it difficult to do that without overly impacting the heel connecting wood surface? Roy Correct - I had a little more than 1/8" sticking up, so I just buzzed it off with my pneumatic angle grinder. As it was I already went a little too deep with the one on the bottom side. That neck heel has VERY little thickness at that point, less than 1/2". |
Author: | Chowlie [ Tue Oct 08, 2019 7:57 am ] |
Post subject: | Re: Takamine Neck Reset Journey |
Finished up all but about 10% of this guitar over the week. Here's a little update for how things went. I ordered a few pieces of 1mm and .5mm maple headstock veneer from LMI and used it to build up the area on the side of the body where I cut too deeply with the saw. This worked perfectly for what I needed. I was able to buzz off most of the excess with an angle grinder and then flatten it down with a block. Attachment: 20191005_122519.jpg Then it was time for some test fitting. Attachment: 20191005_123439.jpg Bass side Attachment: 20191005_164037-min.jpg Treble side Attachment: 20191005_164049.jpg Bass side after further sanding the treble side of the neck. Attachment: 20191005_165100-min-min.jpg Using a fret rocker to help get the side of the neck heel flat. Attachment: 20191005_170215-min.jpg Attachment: 20191005_172355-min.jpg I also further block sanded the end of the body during this process. Attachment: 20191006_145453.jpg
|
Author: | Chowlie [ Tue Oct 08, 2019 8:22 am ] |
Post subject: | Re: Takamine Neck Reset Journey |
During one of the test fits of the neck, my bottom thread insert decided to start pulling out. I applied some super glue to an extra bolt I had and removed the insert. Attachment: 20191006_153833.jpg Here's a good indication of just how thin the heel is. Attachment: 20191006_173117-min.jpg Time to dowel, again Attachment: 20191006_173628.jpg This time my prior concerns came true when the drill bit just walked on through the heel. Oh well. I'm going to machine a little stud to attach a strap button here in the back half of the thread insert. Attachment: 20191006_210856.jpg This time I just left the insert completely intact, as the matching hole in the body was large enough to accept it. Attachment: 20191006_210900.jpg This was my final test fit before gluing and clamping the fretboard extension. See the tiny gap toward the bottom side of the heel? I did a little more work to that the neck morning after the glue dried. Attachment: 20191006_211222.jpg Finally got myself some good clamps for the sake of the fretboard extension. No more fussing around with rubber inner tubes. Don't know why I didn't just get these before, they were only $10 each at Lowes. Attachment: 20191006_220652.jpg Here you can see my latest revision - 1.25" stainless fender washers instead of a machined plate. Works just as good and saves time. As much as I would like the holes to line up well enough to recess the cap screws into the heel block, I have not been able to drill them nearly accurately enough for that to happen. From now on I think I'll just ream the body holes out to 1/2" with my StewMac endpin reamer. This ensures I have enough play in case the thread inserts didn't go into the neck at a perfectly straight angle. It's not the prettiest solution, but it certainly saves time. And that's just one way I can shave dollars off this procedure for others. Attachment: 20191006_221407-min.jpg
|
Author: | Chowlie [ Tue Oct 08, 2019 8:27 am ] |
Post subject: | Re: Takamine Neck Reset Journey |
Here I am contouring the bottom of the heel to the slight radius on the body itself (after the f/b got glued down). That's why there was still a gap present - the heel was perfectly flat on the bottom while the body was curved slightly. I ended up removing a little wood where I didn't intend to on the bass side of the neck, about half an inch from the bottom of the heel. I didn't take a photo, but that's where a little wood filler will come in handy. Lesson learned. Next time I'm going to be sure there is no gap present anywhere before I glue the fretboard, and I'm probably going to block sand the body where the neck attaches until that area is completely flat as well. Attachment: 20191007_072511-min.jpg Might be a little overset for some folks, but this just tells me it'll never need flossing again. Surprisingly, this is just basically where it landed once I cleaned up all the surfaces and got the neck heel flat on the sides. Attachment: 20191007_080306.jpg Turns out, I did have a longer saddle for the non-electric Takamines, but this is all I found when I wanted to string it up. Still works fine, might fit the long saddle later. The intonation was surprisingly spot-on except for the low E and high B, so I compensated those. Attachment: 20191007_080707-min.jpg Voila - for the most part this is done. It's playable, anyway. Need to lower the action on the treble side and refinish the neck heel where I had to sand on it so much. Attachment: 20191007_081117-min.jpg
|
Author: | Chowlie [ Wed Oct 09, 2019 9:25 am ] |
Post subject: | Re: Takamine Neck Reset Journey |
Wipe-on poly is blending in nicely. Attachment: 20191008_215400-min-min.jpg After sanding down to 5000 grit. Attachment: 20191009_061208-min.jpg Attachment: 20191009_064849-min.jpg
|
Author: | jfmckenna [ Thu Oct 10, 2019 3:06 pm ] |
Post subject: | Re: Takamine Neck Reset Journey |
You did a fine job. How's the intonation on it? |
Author: | Chowlie [ Thu Oct 10, 2019 3:12 pm ] |
Post subject: | Re: Takamine Neck Reset Journey |
jfmckenna wrote: You did a fine job. How's the intonation on it? Thank you! Intonation is surprisingly good. I compensated the Low E and high b on the saddle to make it just about perfect. |
Author: | jfmckenna [ Thu Oct 10, 2019 6:32 pm ] |
Post subject: | Re: Takamine Neck Reset Journey |
Chowlie wrote: jfmckenna wrote: You did a fine job. How's the intonation on it? Thank you! Intonation is surprisingly good. I compensated the Low E and high b on the saddle to make it just about perfect. Good. That's the one potential problem with the sawed off method. And since you removed the FB it would have been easy to remedy it. But with those thin saws and a 1/8th inch saddle you can get away with it. I have done one where I had to convert the bridge to a wider saddle probably becasue the orginal position of the bridge wasn't very good. |
Author: | Chowlie [ Fri Oct 11, 2019 7:36 am ] |
Post subject: | Re: Takamine Neck Reset Journey |
jfmckenna wrote: Chowlie wrote: jfmckenna wrote: You did a fine job. How's the intonation on it? Thank you! Intonation is surprisingly good. I compensated the Low E and high b on the saddle to make it just about perfect. Good. That's the one potential problem with the sawed off method. And since you removed the FB it would have been easy to remedy it. But with those thin saws and a 1/8th inch saddle you can get away with it. I have done one where I had to convert the bridge to a wider saddle probably becasue the orginal position of the bridge wasn't very good. Easy to remedy with a veneer of some kind glued back on the heel once flossing was done? I checked the SF95 this morning (the first guitar in my thread) and found the both the low E and high b were ever so slightly sharp at the 12th fret, but barely enough to register with my Kliq tuner. Just normal playing you'd never notice. I can still compensate those on the saddle as well. |
Author: | Chowlie [ Fri Oct 11, 2019 7:47 am ] |
Post subject: | Re: Takamine Neck Reset Journey |
Next up. F363S with the heel coming loose at the back. Attachment: 20191009_211021.jpg Attachment: 20191009_211105.jpg Attachment: 20191009_211107.jpg This one came loose VERY easily compared to the rest. Attachment: 20191010_060637.jpg Attachment: 20191010_061453-min-min.jpg Attachment: 20191010_061555.jpg
|
Author: | Chowlie [ Fri Oct 11, 2019 7:55 am ] |
Post subject: | Re: Takamine Neck Reset Journey |
I went ahead and started to saw a bit, but I really should not have. Once I got through the finish the neck was loose enough to just pull off. So now I'm stuck removing material from the other side of the heel to make it straight. Oh well, another lesson learned. If a doweled neck is pulling up enough to see a gap at the heel cap, then it's probably loose enough to just wiggle off without sawing anything. This might be a guitar I experiment with gluing a .5mm veneer back on the heel. Add to that, if this were a dovetail joint, it's extremely unlikely that you'd see the neck coming up at the back side like this either. Attachment: 20191010_062022.jpg Attachment: 20191010_062225.jpg Attachment: 20191010_062318-min.jpg Attachment: 20191010_062322.jpg Drilled out the existing dowel holes to a larger size and doweled them again. Attachment: 20191011_064918.jpg
|
Author: | jfmckenna [ Fri Oct 11, 2019 8:12 am ] |
Post subject: | Re: Takamine Neck Reset Journey |
Chowlie wrote: Easy to remedy with a veneer of some kind glued back on the heel once flossing was done? I checked the SF95 this morning (the first guitar in my thread) and found the both the low E and high b were ever so slightly sharp at the 12th fret, but barely enough to register with my Kliq tuner. Just normal playing you'd never notice. I can still compensate those on the saddle as well. Yes but it will be noticeable. But I had done that too. I did that on a guitar that had cream colored binding so I shimmed it with a piece of maple finished matched to the binding so it looked intentional. |
Author: | Chowlie [ Fri Oct 11, 2019 8:26 am ] |
Post subject: | Re: Takamine Neck Reset Journey |
jfmckenna wrote: Chowlie wrote: Easy to remedy with a veneer of some kind glued back on the heel once flossing was done? I checked the SF95 this morning (the first guitar in my thread) and found the both the low E and high b were ever so slightly sharp at the 12th fret, but barely enough to register with my Kliq tuner. Just normal playing you'd never notice. I can still compensate those on the saddle as well. Yes but it will be noticeable. But I had done that too. I did that on a guitar that had cream colored binding so I shimmed it with a piece of maple finished matched to the binding so it looked intentional. Eh, won't bother me too much. Call it a feature, not a bug. lol |
Author: | Chowlie [ Thu Oct 17, 2019 9:08 am ] |
Post subject: | Re: Takamine Neck Reset Journey |
Finished up the strap button on the F366S. Carefully chased M5 threads on a 1/4-20 cap screw and tapped the button. Attachment: 72866444_10220389079342719_4650454390400876544_o.jpg Attachment: 73107168_10220389079822731_1455653524300890112_n.jpg I also got a little antsy and pulled the neck back off. The pitch was off just enough to drive me crazy, even though you could barely see it. I needed to remove just a hair of material on the bass side of the heel. Attachment: angle1.jpg Attachment: 20191016_061742.jpg While it's back off I fixed the side marker I melted out previously and sanded through the poly to remove the heat-hazing. Attachment: 20191017_070348.jpg And clamped/glued where the FB came loose about 1" down the neck. Attachment: 20191017_071232.jpg I've also decided I'm going to experiment with a 1mm veneer on the heel before I reattach it to the body. If it works out well it's just a step I'll incorporate in each guitar from now on. The intonation is good enough and sounds fine, but I'll just feel better knowing it's that much closer to the right scale length. |
Page 2 of 3 | All times are UTC - 5 hours |
Powered by phpBB® Forum Software © phpBB Group http://www.phpbb.com/ |